What Indian Social Networking Startups *can* do to survive?
Hello World!
Thats the line most people are taught to print on screen when they first learn any programming language. I’m a programmer by heart, hobby and profession and hence I say hello this way
Anyway, earlier this day, I read a post on Pluggd.in related to the threat that the OpenSocial implementation on Orkut could pose to Indian Social Networking startups (for non-techies, just understand it as the Orkut Application platform like the Facebook platform). And that post coincidently matched my view (in the comment) in the previous post related to BigAdda’s flop show, that Indian Social Networking sites need to get ready to match Orkut’s offering or add another grave in the already populated Internet-Graveyard
Before shouting out my opinion on what Indian Socionets can do to survive. I would like to mimic Clint Eastwood’s famous one-liner “Do ya feel lucky… punk?”. Well do you guys?
Below are a few points on how you can crash into the social networking scene with steaming success. I have considered only a few of the main players into consideration below.
1.) Technical Knowledge: Most Indians lack technical knowledge of HTML and related stuff, which most have in the western countries, so they won’t turn to MySpace. So most won’t appreciate any feature like editing the HTML of your profile.
2.) User Exprience: MySpace is a clutter. They don’t seem to care about User Experience and hence their site design seems to follow the “Anything Goes!” philosophy. Facebook’s design is too complex for newbies to understand. Infact the first time I visited it, it frightened me off. They have too much of data on each page. Orkut’s site design is good and easy to use, but as a developer I have used their sandbox for testing applications for their application platform coming soon. I can surely assure you that they too have screwed up their site’s design with apps. They don’t seem to know how to add allow apps on the already crowded profile page. You can see that when they release their app platform to public sometime later this month. They had a user interface re-design just a couple of months back and hence they surely won’t have a re-design anytime soon. Indians like simplicity (simplicity as in Google’s design). So take the hint.
3.) Page Loads: The internet connection which an average person uses in India is very slow compared to other well-off countries. So heavy sites like Facebook and MySpace take more timme to load. Orkut takes less time to load now. But I say again, there’s a nice 99.99% chance that they will screwup their page loads too when their app platform launches. I checked that by running an app that prints “Hello World”. And it took about 3 seconds to render just that for the first time with no-cache enabled in the app. I could separate say the render time for the app because the app is rendered via javascript after the other parts of the page load (And I know this because I am a involved with the OpenSocial community that helps in implementing the opensocial app platform that Orkut implements). Orkut might be a Google spun site, but even a million web-servers will do no good if the internet connection of the end-user is slow. Thats another hint if you own/soon-to-run a socionet.
4.) Features: Just a couple of years back, the basic idea that a social networking site allows you connect to your friends took the world away by storm, but today it takes more than common features to stay in competition. Just having a photo album, video gallery and profile page will not do today. Its time that you start offering more innovative features. But how are you going to do it if you don’t have any ideas? The best solution is to setup an app platform. Join the OpenSocial alliance and take advantage of its community code. This will enable a feature where other developers can develop apps for your site (just like the Facebook Platform). Orkut, MySpace, Hi5, Plaxo, Flixter and others use this platform. And OpenSocial apps can run on any site that supports OpenSocial (unless the app uses some site-specific features). So an app that runs on a site that supports OpenSocial will run on any other site that supports OpenSocial. This gives you an advantage as there are already apps that you can add to your app directory.
This post covers only broad topics. The rest like privacy, content, etc will be covered in my later posts. If you are interested to know more about this. Just shoot a comment below and I’ll try to cover it in my next posts. Till then cya!
Popularity: 11%
February 23rd, 2008 at 8:02 pm
excellent post dude! will digg it for sure
February 23rd, 2008 at 8:44 pm
What you say regarding Technical Knowledge is spot on! for I tried myspace couple of years ago and found out that I had to code my own page. I din’t login to that EVER again. But I have some reservations regarding what you said about “there’s a nice 99.99% chance that they will screwup their page loads too when their app platform launches” because google guys are just too clever for that. I mean, let me give an example. Try loading gmail, it will take hardly a few secs on a high speed connection; but if you are using a slow connection then you will find that you will get an option saying “the internet connection seems slow, please use the basic html version for now” so we get to go on with our job of composing and reading our emails unhindered. So, I guess they will put an alternate version which loads quicker because they know that staying ahead in this competitive field is extremely vital.
I think its practically very difficult for new players to compete head on with orkut. They have to target some niche if they are to have any chance of success. Let me elaborate. Why did google buy youtube??? why can’t it compete with youtube by releasing a better functioning google videos. The answer is that youtube has come to the scene earlier and it is tough to slug it out with established players.
In terms of search, google defeated established player like yahoo in search because yahoo was like a slumbering senile old giant at a young age. Only because of that google won.
So, unless orkut rests on its laurels and does something really stupid, other social networking startups have hardly any chance whatsoever.
February 23rd, 2008 at 9:28 pm
Kartik,
The post is about *indian* startups and about catering to *indian* users.
So the page loads will matter in India as I said even if google maintains million servers for orkut, they can’t speed up page loads after a mark, since the page load time also depends on the internet connection speed of the end user (mentioned in the post).
Other socionet start ups have a very good chance. The reason: Orkut as I said will lose its trademark features like ‘fast loading’ and ‘easy to use’ once they bring in apps. Since they have already spoilt the user interface as I have seen in their developer sandbox (the gadgets load too slow).
I agree that GMail loads fast even india, but think again! The initial loading time is a lot more. It takes about 5 seconds. And only then they use Ajax to load every message you want to read or to do anything. That is what make users think that its faster. They can’t use the same technique for Orkut. Orkut’s case is different. Think. If every user has a profile and if you want to load every profile the way GMail does. then it will take atleast 5 seconds, because of the apps. Because they have to load a wholly different content. Even if Ajax requests are used for that too. Then it might just reduce to 3.5 to 4 seconds, because common images can be omitted from loading again.
February 24th, 2008 at 9:41 pm
I agree with you, but I would like to add one more thing.. these things should come up to the market with a bang!!!!!!! like people should come to know of it and everyone should develop an interest for it, only then would there be any chance of success. Technology like gmail and orkut are using asp for fast browsing which makes a user with slow net connection use it easily and frquently, like youtube’s buffering is fast than others, wikepedia’s search is gr8 it has huge volumes of data to surf into… but all is used if you know about it and that is known by mouth to mouth advertising not by any tv or radio commercial but you cant tell each and every of 100 crore Indians so to do that we need advertising but it should be done in a different way like interesting road shows with people registering into the site and getting prizes, finding friends etc… it has to be such that the ad is famous and it becomes an icon which brings users to the site…
February 24th, 2008 at 9:47 pm
Yeah I think I missed out that point!
Advertising!
Thanks ritwik (I can’t spell that name, I guess its not is ur name)
Anyway, thats a nice idea and a great point. BidAdda’s TV commercial is of no use!
It can be done better by non-coventional means as u said. Not a road show, but maybe a nice funny prank kinda thing that doesn’t hurt anyone will give a great promotion
I just got this idea because I am a prankster, but I make sure I don’t hurt anyone.
February 25th, 2008 at 9:50 am
yes u r right akash.. my name is ritwik.
April 1st, 2008 at 6:02 am
[…] at least get a break from the torment. “When I washttp://articles.lancasteronline.com/local/4/219036What Indian Social Networking Startups *can* do to survive?Technical Knowledge: Most Indians lack technical knowledge of HTML and related stuff, which most […]
April 7th, 2008 at 9:02 am
Super,its a very good
automated forex signals